|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Holocaust, Pol Pot's Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia, Darfur….
And every time a U.S. president, a British Prime Minister, a U.N. Secretary
General says, "Never again."
Yet it happens-again, and again, and again….
Why? Because, our leaders say, We didn't know.
Yet they did know-recent studies have shown that the British knew conclusively
what was going on at Auschwitz…yet buried that knowledge in their files because
it would have forced them to change their war plans.
Everyone knew what was going on in Cambodia, post-the Vietnam War, as the
Academy Award-winning movie "The Killing Fields" demonstrates … yet the powers
that be declined to admit it, for fear they would have to do something.
In Carla Garapedian's powerful new film, "Screamers," Pulitzer prize-winner
Samantha Power says President after President, Democrat and Republican, have
known about genocides as they were happening … but have chosen not to act.
In Iraq, Reagan did not want the horrors of Saddam Hussein's massacre against
the Kurds to come out, because then he would have to do something to stop him.
In Bosnia, world television coverage of the genocide convinced the international
community to step in…but only after 200,000 had been murdered.
In Rwanda, Bill Clinton did not want the true horrors to come out …because then
he would have to do something. And now, in Darfur, George Bush has finally
declared the desolation of the Southern Sudan a "genocide"-yet refused to do
what it takes to stop it.
Why? Because, once again, as in 1915, when the U.S. ambassador to Turkey, Henry
Morgenthau, first reported the wholesale extermination of the Armenian
population by the Ottoman Turks in Anatolia, it was denied so the United States
would not be forced to act. That reaction gave Hitler his impetus for the
Holocaust: "Who remembers the Armenians?" he declared in 1939, before ordering
the murder of 6 million European Jews.
In "Screamers," Garapedian traces the history of modern-day genocide-and
genocide denial- from the fertile "Holy Mountains" of Anatolia to the current
atrocities in Darfur . This documentary is as shattering as it is powerful,which
includes interviews and live performance footage with System Of A Down, the
multi-platinum, Grammy-Award winning rock band, all of whose members are
Armenian-American. The film is laced with seven of the band's songs from "Holy
Mountains" to "P.L.U.C.K." to the #1 hit "B.Y.O.B." that illuminate the band's
views on political and social issues
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conceived by longtime collaborators Peter McAlevey and Carla Garapedian (herself
an Armenian-American and documentary director of "Lifting the Veil" and
"Children of the Secret State"), "Screamers" came together in the summer 2004
after producer McAlevey ("Radio Flyer," "Shadow Hours") approached System of a
Down's legendary producer Rick Rubin about partnering with the band to make a
documentary about one of their main causes - recognition of the Armenian
genocide.
With Rubin's support, Garapedian met System Of A Down, who endorsed the film's
important message-how the world's denial of the Turk's Armenian genocide
contributed to the continuing crisis of international genocides ever since -
from Armenia to Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia and present-day Darfur.
The cameras followed System Of A Down on their European and American tours last
summer and fall as they promoted their new, two-album set, "Mezmerize" and
"Hypnotize." (Their collective record sales have totaled over 16 million albums
worldwide With the band's cooperation, McAlevey and Garapedian, along with
British producer Nick de Grunwald, secured a deal with BBC Television for UK TV
rights. The film was mainly financed by The Raffy Manoukian Charity in the UK.
Returning to the USA, Garapedian teamed up with McAlevey stalwarts -- DP Charles
Rose, editor Bill Yahraus, post-production supervisor Robin M. Rosenthal and
production manager Don West -- as the band continued its tour in the States. She
attempted to track down House Speaker Dennis Hastert (who, according to Vanity
Fair magazine, has taken $500,000 in campaign contributions from the Turks in
return for allowing an Armenian genocide recognition bill from ever being passed
by the House of Representatives), visited a 100-year-old survivor and, most
importantly, spent time with lead vocalist's Serj Tankian's grandfather, one of
the few remaining eyewitnesses of the genocide.
Finally, just this spring, seven months after staging a protest rally at Dennis
Hastert's offices in Illinois (dubbed "Dennis, Do the Right Thing"), Tankian and
drummer John Dolmayan confronted Hastert in the Capital Rotunda … luckily, the
cameras were there.
With an ending filmed in the actual village in Turkey where the massacre of
Tankian's ancestors began, set against the ghostly strains of the hit "Holy
Mountains," Garapedian's film comes full circle from 1915 through the horrors of
20th and 21st Century genocide in Darfur … to a finale of ghostly images of real
ancestors that will never be forgotten
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
While most of the concert footage had been handled in Europe, Garapedian faced
the harder challenge of linking it all to the current political debate on
genocide - in Europe, Turkey and the United States. In America, the pressure was
on the Bush Administration to acknowledge its own historical record and
recognize the first genocide of the 20th Century, thus setting the stage for a
worldwide recognition and reparations. Here luck played a hand again-while age
alone has decimated the population of eyewitness survivors of the massacres, one
turned out to be Serj's own grandfather, Stepan Haytayan. Stepan is one of the
only survivors who survived the death march from Efkere, the village Serj's
family came from in Turkey.
Fortunately, despite being in poor health, Serj's grandfather had been
videotaped by Serj a few years earlier and that, combined with Carla's research
on the village from historical archives in Harvard and Britain, helped flesh out
the story of what happened the day the massacres started and the forced death
marches that followed.
Then, luck intervened again -in the middle of this process word reached the
filmmakers that an Armenian-American survivor of the genocide had just turned
100 in Connecticut … and received a letter from Vice-President Dick Cheney
congratulating her on her good fortune in surviving the "Armenian genocide." It
was the first time a ranking American vice-president had ever used the "g-word"
officially to describe what the Turks had done. All of this just at the time the
State Department was in the process of recalling its U.S. Ambassador to Armenia
for using the "g-word" in connection with the Armenian genocide. And also at a
time when Congress was being asked to recognize the genocide and Speaker of the
House, Dennis Hastert, was in the political hot-seat, not least by the FBI
whistle-blower, Sibel Edmonds, who consented to appear in the film.
Racing to Connecticut to interview this survivor before the White House could
recall the letter, Garapedian also had the good fortune to interview Henry
Morgenthau III, whose grandfather had been the U.S. Ambassador to Turkey at the
time and witnessed the massacres with his own eyes, as well Pulitzer
prize-winning Harvard Professor Samantha Power, whose 2002 book "A Problem from
Hell: America and the Age of Genocide" demonstrates how all the subsequent
genocides of the 20th and 21st Centuries date back to our simple inability to
admit what the Turks did to the Armenians. Again, as Hitler said in ordering the
destruction of European Jewry, "Who remembers the Armenians?"
Well, Power does-as does every Armenian, anywhere in the world. As do Rwandans
who have an exhibit on the Armenian genocide at the very sight where the worst
killing was perpetrated. As Power argues in the movie, the problem with genocide
is "you can't kill them all; there are always survivors." And those survivors,
Power says, become the "Screamers," the one's who can't rest until the world
knows what has happened -
Elie Wiesel on the Holocaust, David Puttnam making "The Killing Fields" about
what happened in Cambodia, Dennis Quaid giving a year of his life to a film
about Bosnia or Don Cheadle starring in the acclaimed "Hotel Rwanda."
And, in the end, that's what "Screamers" is all about-an internationally
produced film by an equally international crew that uses the music of a band of
genocide survivors to explicate one of the great questions of our time: can we
stop genocide? Do we really mean 'never again?'
In the end, as lead singer Serj Tankian stands, surveying mountains very like
those of his native Anatolia (and System's mournful song "Holy Mountains" plays
in the background), Garapedian's cameras track through the rocky remains of
Efkere, his grandfather's ruined village, as images of the sacrifice in each
household appear and the roll call of the dead continues: "Armenia-1.5 million
dead; The Holocaust-6 million dead; Cambodia-2 million dead; Rwanda-800,000
dead; Bosnia-200,000 dead; Darfur-400,000 dead…and counting."
As Serj Tankian says at the end: "I think we should all be Screamers."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CARLA GARAPEDIAN:
Family village in Turkey: Van and Sivas, Born USA
I grew up in Los Angeles with two identities - Armenian and American. Both sets
of grandparents were survivors. So I knew who I was. I left the U.S. in 1979 to
make films about human rights atrocities in other countries -- I've travelled to
many countries in the world, trying to tell other people's stories. But it
wasn't until this film that I could tell the story of my own people.
The denial of the Armenian genocide has motivated me in my work for as long as I
can remember. It's not a conscious thing - it's just there, simmering under
every story I've done about atrocities governments would like to keep hidden,
truths people would seek to deny.
All of the Armenians I know are scarred by this event. We are children and
grandchildren of survivors - how can we forget? Elie Wiesel says denial is the
last stage of genocide. It is when the perpetrator seeks to become the victim
and make the victim the perpetrator. That is why we can't rest until our own
government stops speaking out of both sides of its mouth - our historical
records can't say one thing, and our politicians another. We can not rewrite
history. That's Orwellian.
I remember seeing a documentary about a war crime in Croatia. A grave was being
dug up by forensic pathologists. It was very difficult to watch because the
bodies had not completely decomposed. But it was compelling because the chief
forensic pathologist said something I can never forget: dead men can't speak,
but their bodies do not lie about their deaths. So how is it that the death of
over a million people can be denied? Is it only the passage of time that allows
such a monstrous atrocity, which was so well publicized at the time, to be
forgotten?
System of a Down gave me the chance to tell this story. Their music, their
passion - and the young people who follow them - have made this film possible.
Their music is the music of life, of survival - it is saying, we are here. We
remember.
The Armenian genocide wasn't the first in history - but it is the first that was
within our collective memory. "Why do genocides continue in the 21st century?"
asks one of our contributors. "Because those who perpetrated them in the 20th
century got away it." That is the message. Those who forget the past are
condemned to repeat it.